Living in Fairport, NY - 2026 Housing Guide
Fairport combines the charm of an Erie Canal village with one of Monroe County's top school districts - a perennial favorite among buyers who want community character alongside academic excellence.
$285,000
Median Home Price
2.45%
Effective Tax Rate
A-
Fairport CSD
20 min
Commute to Downtown
About Fairport, NY
Fairport may be Monroe County's most beloved small town. The Erie Canal runs directly through the village, creating a walkable waterfront scene with restaurants, ice cream shops, an iconic lift bridge, and towpath access stretching in both directions. The Fairport CSD is highly regarded and has one of the strongest music and arts programs in the region. Homes range from Victorian-era village houses to modern colonials in surrounding neighborhoods. While the commute to downtown takes 20 minutes, the town's self-contained character means many residents need to leave only occasionally. The market is competitive - Fairport homes rarely sit unsold, and multiple-offer situations are common.
Why Buyers Choose Fairport
- Fairport CSD rated A- - one of Monroe County's top districts with exceptional arts programs
- Walkable Erie Canal village with year-round restaurants, festivals, and towpath access
- Strong community identity and neighborhood association activity
- Lower tax rate (2.45%) than Brighton despite comparable school quality
- Mix of charming village homes and newer suburban construction
- Regular community events: Canal Days festival, farmers market, Canal Concert Series
Pros & Cons
Pros
- +Top-tier school district with strong arts/music
- +Walkable canal village - rare in Monroe County
- +Strong community character
- +More affordable than Brighton
- +Great resale value and demand
Cons
- −20-minute commute to downtown
- −Village homes have older infrastructure
- −Market is very competitive
- −Limited new construction in village area
Frequently Asked Questions About Fairport
What is the median home price in Fairport NY?
As of early 2026, the median home price in Fairport NY is approximately $285,000. Village homes closer to the canal are priced at a premium ($300K-$500K+) while outlying neighborhoods start around $185,000-$220,000. Fairport offers Brighton-comparable school quality at a lower price point.
How are Fairport CSD schools rated?
Fairport CSD earns an A- rating and is one of Monroe County's most respected districts. The district is particularly known for its performing arts programs - Fairport High School's music department is nationally recognized. Academic performance is in the top tier for Monroe County.
What is the Fairport Erie Canal lift bridge?
The Fairport lift bridge is a manually-operated canal bridge and local landmark. It lifts to allow boat traffic during the navigation season (May-November) and serves as the centerpiece of the Canal Days summer festival, one of Monroe County's largest community events.
Is Fairport or Brighton better for families?
Both are excellent choices. Brighton offers a shorter commute (10 min vs 20 min) and slightly higher school rankings but comes with significantly higher property taxes (3.61% vs 2.45%). Fairport provides a more community-oriented village feel with strong schools at lower tax cost. Many families choose Fairport specifically for the quality-of-life character of the village.
Property Tax Estimate
Monthly Payment Estimate
Based on $285,000 home, 10% down, 6.03% rate